home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=89TT1245>
- <title>
- May 08, 1989: No Tears, But No Comfort
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1989
- May 08, 1989 Fusion Or Illusion?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- BOOKS, Page 97
- No Tears, but No Comfort
- </hdr><body>
- <p>By Paul Gray
- </p>
- <qt> <l>COLLECTED POEMS</l>
- <l>by Philip Larkin</l>
- <l>edited by Anthony Thwaite Farrar</l>
- <l>Straus & Giroux; 330 pages; $22.50</l>
- </qt>
- <p> Philip Larkin, the pre-eminent poet in English of his time,
- died, after a brief struggle with cancer, in 1985, at age 63.
- Soon afterward his diaries were shredded, as he had instructed,
- at the library of England's Hull University, where he had worked
- for 30 years in self-elected obscurity. His manuscripts and
- unpublished poems escaped a similar fate thanks to a
- contradiction in his will: one clause called for the destruction
- of these papers, while another allowed trustees of the estate
- the right to decide which ones merited publication. Given the
- choice between guillotine and press, the issue can hardly have
- been in much doubt. Larkin might have had mixed feelings about
- his Collected Poems, which contains more than 80 pieces never
- before seen in print and some two dozen previously uncollected
- in book form. But the poet's army of admirers -- solitary types,
- for the most part, who are often surprised to bump into fellow
- enlistees -- need suffer no such scruples. This volume only
- enhances Larkin's imposing stature.
- </p>
- <p> The nature of his triumph, though, is elusive and peculiar.
- Larkin and his contemporaries inherited the scorched earth of
- modernism -- the towering shadow cast by Yeats, the
- multilingual complexities introduced by Eliot and Pound, the
- daunting technical virtuosity of Auden. Starting out, Larkin had
- the good taste to imitate all these (except Pound), with some
- Dylan Thomas thrown in for good measure. He got out from under
- his predecessors only when he learned to lower his voice, to
- submerge complexities of thought and feeling beneath a serene,
- limpid surface.
- </p>
- <p> A turning point seems to have been reached in 1948, in the
- never-before-published "An April Sunday brings the snow."
- Larkin remembers his father, recently dead, and the plum jam
- preserves he had put up: "Which now you will not sit and eat./
- Behind the glass, under the cellophane,/ Remains your final
- summer -- sweet/ And meaningless, and not to come again." The
- fatalism of that last line strikes Larkin's most distinctive
- note. He is not a poet to seek out for soothing assurances.
- Mortality haunted him. At age 24 he writes, "Death is a cloud
- alone in the sky with the sun./ Our hearts, turning like fish
- in the green wave,/ Grow quiet in its shadow." Some 31 years
- later, this confession:
- </p>
- <qt> <l>I work all day, and get half-drunk</l>
- <l>at night. Waking at four to soundless dark,</l>
- <l>I stare.</l>
- <l>In time the curtain-edges will grow light.</l>
- <l>Till then I see what's really always</l>
- <l>there:</l>
- <l>Unresting death, a whole day</l>
- <l>nearer now . . . </l>
- </qt>
- <p> Rubbing noses in such gloom is only one of the demands
- Larkin makes on his readers. He also boasts (and sometimes
- complains) about his exclusion from everyday life, his marginal
- role as a bachelor librarian, living alone and not growing
- mellow with age. In fact, Larkin makes of his infirmities a
- caricature, given to grim, plain speech: "Man hands on misery
- to man./ It deepens like a coastal shelf./ Get out as early as
- you can,/ And don't have any kids yourself." This apparition
- even mocks literature. Admitting that his youthful joy in
- reading has paled, he advises, "Get stewed:/ Books are a load
- of crap."
- </p>
- <p> Such directives do not seem calculated to make a poet
- beloved, which Larkin was and is. What rescues his work from the
- slough of depression is the fun he makes of being alive,
- between parenthetical darknesses, and of himself:
- </p>
- <qt> <l>Sexual intercourse began</l>
- <l>In nineteen sixty-three</l>
- <l>(Which was rather late for me) --</l>
- <l>Between the end of the Chatterley ban</l>
- <l>And the Beatles' first LP.</l>
- </qt>
- <p> These are his five most famous lines; all Larkinites have
- them by heart. In the expanded context of the Collected Poems,
- though, this stanza seems not only funny but also perfectly
- serious. Every generation imagines that the next one will have
- things easier. In "High Windows" Larkin wonders if his elders,
- thinking of him, expected that "He/ And his lot will all go down
- the long slide/ Like free bloody birds." It has not worked out
- that way, the poet suggests, even as he ironically envies the
- children of the swinging '60s their tantalizing, illusory
- liberties.
- </p>
- <p> Ultimately, the sense of conditional freedom illuminates
- all his best work, which is to say nearly everything in this
- book. Oddly enough, given his Oxford education and bookish life,
- Larkin was one of the century's greatest pastoral poets. "At
- Grass" (about retired racehorses) and "First Sight" (about
- winter-born lambs) are hymns to the inexorable rhythms of the
- seasons, to which each human, unfortunately, has only a
- short-term invitation. "Church Going" deals with a man-made
- structure. A wayward cyclist stops out of curiosity and enters
- an empty house of worship: "Once I am sure there's nothing going
- on/ I step inside, letting the door thud shut." That offhand
- "nothing going on" builds slowly to signify a loss of faith, of
- ritual and communal practices. There are no tears, but neither
- is there comfort; we are, for better and worse, all on our own.
- </p>
- <p> Is such loneliness preferable to the enforced communities
- of our forebears? Larkin does not pretend to know, or say.
- Instead, his poems address the selves that most people prefer
- to keep hidden during works and days: the nagging voice that
- wonders whether one choice was worth an infinity of losses.
- Impossible to answer; impossible, while reading Larkin or after,
- to forget.
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-